“Nhặt sạn” hay văn hóa phản biện lệch chuẩn trên mạng xã hội?
Thời gian gần đây, trên mạng xã hội xuất hiện ngày càng nhiều hiện tượng mà người ta quen gọi là “nhặt sạn”-chỉ ra sai sót trong các bài viết, công trình nghiên cứu, hoặc phát biểu của người khác. Bản thân việc phát hiện sai sót không phải là điều tiêu cực, nhưng cách thức thực hiện việc “nhặt sạn”, từ thái độ, ngôn từ đến mục đích, lại đang đặt ra nhiều vấn đề đáng suy nghĩ đối với văn hóa tranh luận.
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