“Nhặt sạn” hay văn hóa phản biện lệch chuẩn trên mạng xã hội?
Thời gian gần đây, trên mạng xã hội xuất hiện ngày càng nhiều hiện tượng mà người ta quen gọi là “nhặt sạn”-chỉ ra sai sót trong các bài viết, công trình nghiên cứu, hoặc phát biểu của người khác. Bản thân việc phát hiện sai sót không phải là điều tiêu cực, nhưng cách thức thực hiện việc “nhặt sạn”, từ thái độ, ngôn từ đến mục đích, lại đang đặt ra nhiều vấn đề đáng suy nghĩ đối với văn hóa tranh luận.
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